 +86-19522756236  IMD@screwtech.cn
You are here: Home » Daily Update » Technical Support » Comparison of planetary roller screw and ball screw

Comparison of planetary roller screw and ball screw

Views:1     Author:Site Editor     Publish Time: 2021-02-19      Origin:Site

■Comparison of movement mechanism and force state 


Rolling element

Circulating motion of rolling body

Force state of rolling element

Centrifugal force of rolling element

Pure rolling ratio

Planetary roller screw

Threaded small roller

The small threaded roller makes planetary motion around the screw axis

The rolling element has a large cross-sectional area and is loaded at any time without cyclic alternating stress.

Planetary mechanism prevents centrifugal force

Very High

Ball screw

Ball

Reverse mechanism to achieve circular scrolling

The ball has a small cross-sectional area and is intercepted in turn, generating cyclic alternating stress.

Large centrifugal force will be generated when running at high speed

Higher (sometimes "wedge effect")

Comparison of principle and structure
As shown in the figure on the right: the structure of the planetary roller screw is similar to that of the ball screw, the difference is that the load transmission element of the planetary roller screw is a threaded roller instead of a ball. The advantage is that there are numerous threads to support the load.

The roller in the planetary roller screw design structure is non-circulating, so its rotation speed is twice that of the ball screw. The design of the ball screw is that the balls are circulating, so the balls will collide when rotating at high speed.

Since the lead is a function of the pitch of the planetary roller screw, the lead can be designed as an integer or a decimal. The lead of the ball screw is limited by the diameter of the ball, so the lead will be standard.


Comparison of service life:

Both planetary roller screws and ball screws apply to Hertz's law. From the law of Hertz pressure, we can conclude that the static load of the planetary roller screw is 3 times that of the ball screw, and the life span is 10-15 times that of the ball screw.


Latest Blog
31 / 03 / 2021
The relationship between ball screw preload and accuracy

The relationship between the pre-pressure of the ball screw and the load of the screw is mainly used for gap adjustment. If high precision is required, the pre-pressure should be increased accordingly, but it should not be too large, otherwise it will cause high temperature and reduced efficiency.

Read More
30 / 03 / 2021
Ball screw drive torque

What is the ball screw drive torque? How should this torque be calculated? The torque of the mechanical components is called the driving torque of the ball screw. The ball screw will produce a certain degree of torsional deformation under the action of torque. Torque is the basic load form of transm

Read More
29 / 03 / 2021
Introduction of Rotating Ball Spline

Features of Rotating SeriesZero clearance in spline rotation direction/high positioning accuracyThe contact angle between the nut and the steel ball is 40°, and the bearing DB type (back-to-back combination) design is adopted. Due to the wide span between the effective centers of the bead groove, th

Read More
26 / 03 / 2021
Ball screw axial load

SCREWTECH ball screw mechanisms are usually used together with guide components (such as linear guides, linear bearings). The ball screw mechanism only provides the axial force required by the ball nut to make the worktable move in the direction of linear motion, and the worktable as the load and th

Read More
25 / 03 / 2021
The solution to the loud noise of the ball screw

Precision ground ball screw for Automated Adhesive Dispensing MachinesAutomated adhesive dispensing solutions are configurable for one and two-component chemistries and process a variety of material volumes, viscosities and temperature specifications. Designed to consistently deliver accurate ratios

Read More
24 / 03 / 2021
Ball screw support unit basic knowledge

The ball screw support unit is a fixed unit connecting ball screw and motor, which can ensure that the center height of the two ends of the ball screw is the same. Common models are: BK+BF series, EK+EF series, AK+AF series, FK+FF series, WBK series, today we will introduce the WBK series ball screw

Read More

Make Business Easier

Screwtech designs, manufactures, supplies a complete selection of inch and metric linear mechanical parts and systems to the Linear Motion and Power Transmission Industries.

View More >

Leave a message
​Copyright © SCREWTECH  All Rights Reserved. Site Map  Designed by iwonder.cn